The value of making something: Shop Class as Soulcraft
I read this mini review on Relevant Magazine’s online newsletter today. I thought it was interesting. There does seem to be a return to creation, making tangible things with our hands, and placing value on those who do. It’s another way of keeping life a little bit more local in the midst of our global society!
I haven’t read this book yet…it’s now on my list.
From Relevant Magazine….
7. Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work, by Matthew B. Crawford
A philosopher/mechanic, Michael Crawford explores the benefits, both for the individual and for the community, of the manual trades in Shop Class as Soulcraft. Drawing on his own experience as an electrician and a motorcycle mechanic, as well as the experiences of other craftsmen he encounters, Crawford challenges the prevalent assumption that college is for everyone and articulates the difference between the “knowing how” required of the trades and the “knowing what” stressed in the modern American education system. “Practical know-how,” Crawford argues convincingly, “is always tied to the experience of a particular person. It can’t be downloaded, it can only be lived.” Shop Class as Soulcraft is an especially salient read in today’s economic environment and calls us to reconsider how good work is defined in 21st century America.
—Sara Sterley lives near Indianapolis, IN and regularly contributes book reviews to RELEVANT.
It’s all about going local: 15th Ave Coffee and Tea
Check out the 15th Ave Coffee and Tea on Capitol Hill in Seattle. The coffee shop opened on July 24th, and represents a new wave of concept in coffee shops, a concept that readers of Coffee Shop Journal will recognize immediately: local coffee shops built around community. The only surprising thing? 15th Ave is actually a Starbucks store.
Normally, if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, we assume it is a duck. In this case, there’s not a whole lot “duck like” about the new concept. It doesn’t look much like a Starbucks, except in that family-resemblance kind of way when your great Aunt tells you all the cousins look alike. There is a great flickr photo slideshow here that gives some detailing in the new store.
So what makes makes 15th Ave different? Here’s what I’ve seen so far:
- The concept of “local” resonates with all of us right now. We want to now and be known, and Starbucks is working to understand that concept.
- 15th Ave can offer smaller batch coffees, different brewing methods and new selections without alienating the Starbucks audience.
- 15th Ave can offer local pastries without worrying about the “keep in consistent” cry from customers. They can offer new choices at will. They can experiment with offerings that Starbucks can’t touch, such as beer or wine sales.
- Local musicians and groups will be more likely to play in and patronize local shops.
All of this, of course, does not go down easily with the skeptical coffee-drinking public. Some naysayers refuse to consider 15th Ave a local shop if it is “inspired by Starbucks” (which is what its signage says). There is some question as to how Starbucks can translate the local concept into other local venues. And of course, there is that family resemblance that people will notice.
In the meantime, I guess it’s back to Seattle I go again!


