What Would You Do? Learn their name!
I watched an episode of ABC Primetime’s “What Would You Do?” tonight. I could probably write forever about the moral dilemmas they pose to unsuspecting passersby. One scene struck me in particular tonight. An actor poses as a homeless man collapsing on the street. The question is, how long will it take bystanders to call an ambulance? Turns out, quite a long time. To exacerbate the matter, the producers put a can of beer in the actor’s “passed out” hand. With this scenario, it took much longer for a bystander to call for help.
And then…
And then a homeless woman herself stopped next to the collapsed man and asked passersby to call an ambulance. Eventually (nearly 100 people later), the homeless woman gets a stranger to call in for help. While waiting for the ambulance, the homeless woman literally invents a name for the passed out man and begins comforting him. “Billy, you’re still here. You’re going to make it. You’ll be ok Billy.” When the woman began using “Billy’s” name, other bystanders began to follow the woman’s lead and help out as well.
Wow.
The power of a name, even if it isn’t a real name.
There is a lesson there for us in dealing with people we meet. Their names are their right to exist their personality, their life. How small a thing it is to find out their name and use it.


Hi!
I was so moved by this woman…. AND furious that ABC is so blatantly traumatizing people like her. This is completely unethical and immoral.
I want to find this woman and reach out to her.
I was relaying the story to a friend and forgot to mention how she had given him a name. She is an angel.
Amazing…
I love this show…I agree it can traumatize people but I think that the benefits are worth it (for those of us who can learn from how others behave in some of these situations) I just saw the follow up to the Linda Hamilton segment last night and I am a different person today. I had no idea that she gave him a name…wow She is my hero, I aspire to be more like her. I am so blown away by this story…wonderful. Again, I think that the ends justify the means with this show…yeah a few people may be embarrassed or stressed out but what it teaches the viewers is so important. I hope this show stays on and I hope that if I ever encounter one of these situations I will do “what is right”
I love “What Would You Do”. That woman is a couragious woman and shows that just because she is homless, it does NOT mean she doesn’t have a heart. I’m even writing a story about people who I hear about that have courage, hearts and faith and stuff. I’ve been working on it for six months!! If anyone has any storys, I’d be glad to hear. E-mail me at jroseweitz@yahoo.com